How does Mandarin sound to you?

I'm American but I grew up speaking Mandarin at home. I'm just curious, for those of you who are new to Rednote and Mandarin, how does it sound? Is it pretty, ugly, sing-songy, guttural etc.....? I won't be offended whatever you say.

Comments

Shetlandsheepzover 1 year ago2

Definitely sing-songi, I think an equivalent to other languages to me is similar to Italian or Minnesota accent where it's just a lovely note. But my ear is very rough and I can't distinguish between regional accents.

jo_nigiriover 1 year ago2

I find it extremely pleasant-sounding along with Japanese, but my mom doesn't like the sound of Mandarin and thinks it's too... shh... tz... ch.. Does that make sense 😂

Lucky-Past8459over 1 year ago1

It's sing songy to me and sometimes a little harsh but I think I just haven't listened enough yet to start recognizing the sound of it

I like Chinese opera, I think it sounds really awesome, first time I heard it was Genshin

AlexRatorover 1 year ago1

I'm Chinese myself and my native language is Mandarin, so this might sound a bit weird coming from me.

I really dislike how Mandarin sounds.

Overall it just sounds so harsh. The retroflex consonants like zh ch sh and the rapid change in pitch due the tones really prove this. In comparison Cantonese sounds a lot softer and much more elegant. Even angrily swearing in Cantonese sounds more pleasant than normal Madarin

Also it's definitely the most "alien" of the Chinese tongues. It ditched all the final consonants like -m -t -k -b all together, and greatly reduced the number of valid syllables, making many previously distinct characters sound the same.

HOWEVER, once you start reading classical Chinese or poetry in Mandarin... oh boy, complete 180º

Due to the fact that there are no final consonants other than -n and -ng, each syllable just flows into the next. The rise and falls turns into a music-like melody. imo the sound of reading old texts in Mandarin completely beats all other dialects, past and present

_HopSkipJump_over 1 year ago1

TV media presenters and voiceovers sound hilarious to me. Especially male voices, they sound so theatrical and camp with over emphasizing every word. I don't know if this is a cultural thing because I've also noticed in formal public occasions (announcing best wishes to the couple at weddings) a similar voice style is used in an almost ritualistic monotone, very loud and forceful too. I'm sure there's a long history behind this which I'm fascinated to learn about.

Otherwise_Face5492over 1 year ago1

Honestly wished they chose another southern chinese dialect to be official langauge of china instead. Mandarin is a pretty new dialect too, not as close to old/middle chinese. There are many ancient chinese dialects that are more closer to old/middle chinese. Dialects like Shanghainese, hokkien, hakka sound a little better, and they are more closer to old/middle chinese.

Mandarin originated from the North of China, and to be honest I think Northern chinese dialects and accents sound very annoying. Southern Chinese dialects and accents sound much better. Taiwanese accent also originates from Southern China(derived from the Quanzhou-Zhangzhou dialect of the Minnan dialect) because most taiwanese people came from southern china. And taiwanese and southern chinese talking sounds much better.

ohfaithover 1 year ago1

I love how it sounds but I'm very bias and I've been living around Asia for 11 years 😂 I've always been interested in languages and culture (not limited to Asia). it's very... I don't know. sing songy? I wish I could do it! the music makes me feel very calm and sooth (mandopop)

totoGalaxiasover 1 year ago1

I like it a lot. The tones are sutil. I speak spanish as a first language, so really hard "r" sounds. The r sounds in mandarin sound more like english speakers to me

Material-Ad4473over 1 year ago1

It’s very different depending on who is speaking. Northerners in Beijing sound totally different from the Mandarin spoken in Guilin and Canton. It’s like the USA California Vs Boston Vs Louisiana twang. It’s interesting but sometimes it takes a couple seconds to understand something that didn’t sound like what I’m familiar to.

Ill_Walrus_throwawayover 1 year ago1

Depends on the speaker. Overall it sounds sophisticated and quick. The tones give a sense of cool indifference. Like the intonation is not governed by emotion as it is in English, but something more reserved.

More like this

Making the Jump from TikTok to Rednote(Xiaohongshu)? Here’s What You Need to Know

So you’re thinking about switching (or at least dabbling) from TikTok to **Rednote** (aka Xiaohongshu)? Here’s a quick rundown on what to expect and how to adapt: 1. **Different Vibe** * **TikTok** is all about short, snappy videos—dances, trends, and memes. * **Rednote** leans more toward lifestyle tips, product reviews, and personal stories. Think mini-blogs rather than just quick clips. 2. **Less is More—or Is It?** * On **TikTok**, you can go viral with a 15-second masterpiece. * On **Rednote**, people actually read captions and appreciate detailed posts. Don’t be afraid to write a bit more and share personal insights. 3. **Engage with the Community** * Responding to comments is key on both platforms, but **Rednote** users expect a friendlier, more helpful approach. Focus on real interaction rather than just racking up views. 4. **Use Relevant Hashtags & Keywords** * **TikTok** hashtags can be trendy and fleeting. * **Rednote** hashtags and keywords should be more targeted, especially if you’re reviewing products or sharing how-to tips. 5. **Be Ready for Culture Shifts** * The **Rednote** audience often loves beauty, travel, fashion, and “real-life” hacks. * If you’re pivoting from dance challenges, consider experimenting with lifestyle or review content to fit the platform’s style. 6. **Quality Over Quantity** * While **TikTok** can reward frequent posting, **Rednote** might favor fewer, well-thought-out posts that really resonate. High-quality visuals and genuine storytelling go a long way. Got questions about Rednote? Drop ’em below—always happy to help a fellow content creator make the jump!

over 1 year ago
185107

The ban isn't really about privacy concerns

Why exactly? You and me know why America is banning tiktok... They can't control the narrative their like they do with Facebook or Instagram YouTube. etc The genocide in Gaza was being shown in its full without any kind of censorship... And daddy israel doesn't like that so the AIPAC who's holding the American politicians by the balls... Forced them into banning the app.... It's not about privacy or any of that.... Remember edward Snowden.? I rest my case.

over 1 year ago
13770

Y'all know why Trump suddenly became "pro-TikTok" right?

Say it with me....because he and his oligarch buddies are getting worried Americans are waking up to the truth about the anti-China propaganda BS in Red Note and will either demand better conditions or go full socialist.

over 1 year ago
11749