PoE 2 builds are a lot more straightforward than PoE 1 because the skill design is far less flexible. For the most part, each skill is designed to synergize with a few other specific skills, and you cannot freely mash together a rotation that mixes multiple “skill groups” together because the interactions just aren’t there — this is especially true of attack/weapon skills. Don’t fight these pre-determined archetypes… just pick a weapon intended for your class and read through the available skills to figure out which ones work together. It should be fairly obvious. Ranger Lightning Arrow + Lightning Rod for example: drop rods then shoot LA for a massive burst of damage… but trying to mix them with gas/explosive/poison skills just has no beneficial interaction at all.
Once you find a strong combo of 2-3 skills intended to work together, start reading up on how to scale damage for it and path towards relevant nodes on the passive tree. The passive tree is a mess in PoE 2 so you’ll have to basically hover over everything in a large radius to find a few useful clusters.
I know you said you don’t want to use guides, but I would highly recommend visiting poe.ninja and selecting your choice of ascendency and main skill. You don’t have to look at or copy any specific player’s build for this to be helpful. Take a look at the Passive Heatmap to get a rough idea of how other people are pathing around the tree and which clusters benefit your build at all. Take a look at support gems and uniques that people are using and then decide for yourself.