Maybe it's time to say it: "XHS (RedNote) is not an accurate depiction of China/Chinese people. Its denizens never claimed it was."

This app is NOT a replacement for our American apps. It was not made for us. So...

  • No, you will not learn "the truth" about China and the Chinese from it, just as you will not learn the truth about American politics from Fox or CNN
  • No, you will not beat the system into submission by purposefully posting things to get yourself banned (you may, however, get all of is kicked off the app, if enough of you wish that for us out of spite or childishness)
  • No, the Chinese people on XHS are not deliberately lying to you about what their lives are like in China; judging ALL nearly 1.5 BILLION Chinese on just ~100 posts you've seen on XHS is like judging all Americans by watching how our celebrities behave
  • Yes, some people are much, much better off than others in China; some have wonderful apartments in a city like Shanghai and some live in poverty in the derelict villages of a province like Guizhou
    • When in doubt about this... look to yourself: Can you not think of something comparable in the US? For example: those who live in New York City or San Francisco vs those who live in villages in Virginia? Which side do we show to the world in our most popular shows (i.e. Friends)?
  • Yes, you can actually still learn quite a lot about Chinese culture from XHS, but understand that this is not an American app; it was not made for Americans living under the American Constitution

If none of this makes sense and you still want to pick little fights here and there... there is always X. There is always Meta. There is always whatever will become of TikTok.

And if you want a comprehensive information source of ALL ~1.4 billion Chinese citizens, an app is definitely not the place to find it. The same goes for apps like TikTok, where "everyone" can apparently post and "be seen". Do you think all Americans are represented on TikTok? (If so, we're in more trouble than we thought.)

So, for those of you who get what I'm saying (even from the title), this isn't a message for you. But for those who feel a strong desire to downvote this simply because it's rubbing you the wrong way or you have a different opinion... Please reflect and reconsider.

Share

Comments

Expensive-Bed-9169β€’almost 2 years agoβ€’6

Some of us are capable of drawing sensible conclusiond from incomplete data. There are many very friendly people and very few arseholes in China (and yes, I have been there). Nearly all of the Chinese population has been lifted out of poverty in the last few decades, unlike America were many are being forced into it. Compare medical, education, infrastructure etc etc and China is far ahead. You need to accept that America is failing most of its citizens.

EffYourCouchβ€’almost 2 years agoβ€’3

100%. It's a good place to see what China's like according to the people that are allowed to show you things so you won't see any poverty or really anything negative at all.

You'll be able to meet some friendly people and learn things that you may had no idea about to begin with. For example; I had no idea that it was ok to be openly gay in China. Also, it's ok to be trans but you have to have the bottom-surgery and have the government change your ID to say you're the gender you want to be.

Also, their government treats their citizens great and no one has anything negative or even critical to say about the government...it's like a utopia there./s

caffeinatedteapotβ€’almost 2 years agoβ€’3

Anything negative gets deleted. I've saved a screenshot of several before they were deleted. This is not a comment from someone who has a good work/life balance.

https://preview.redd.it/slmsdp90y9ee1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e4a4f1aeee359df51430a70cbd6d5e46038f65c0

TotallyNotCIA_Opsβ€’almost 2 years agoβ€’3

Haha Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk, starting your own Reddit account just to post this is shit is wild wild work guys! πŸ˜‚

bjran8888β€’almost 2 years agoβ€’2

So you're seriously saying that the people up there are lying to you?

There's nothing more real than direct communication.

L0n3_N0n3nt1tyβ€’almost 2 years agoβ€’2

Look. Obviously china has problems. I'm not trying to move there. But this exchange of culture and voices. This is a bridge when lately everyone had been building walls.. or worse

Pandabumoneβ€’almost 2 years agoβ€’2

I'm treating it like a penpal/postcard kind of site. And for learning about language, culture, food, all that. I don't really go looking for political or controversial things on the app; I'm there to get away from those things and just meet some normal people. It's been the most refreshing and mentally restoring social media experience I've had in probably a decade.

cherrylpkβ€’almost 2 years agoβ€’1

It’s not that deep for me bro. I just want to see videos of cats.

Tiny_University1793β€’almost 2 years agoβ€’1

Yes. The best way you wanna get the truth is buy a ticket and get there to see by yourself.

More like this

r/rednote

Anyone else tired of rednote colonization or is it just me?

I get that I'm probably part of the problem because I too am a tiktok refugee, but i hate logging onto xiaohongshu and just seeing all the same american tiktok creators on there. like no, show me the chinese content, i dont care about nmillz anymore

almost 2 years ago
10Β· 86%7
r/rednote

rant: i really hate rednote

I'm Chinese, and I've been living in China for 6 years now. I did briefly grow up in Canada, which, honestly, brutally fucked up my Chinese when I was younger, which means that my Chinese is nearly native level speaking-wise, not so much texting-wise. I hate the glaze that abcs/cbcs get for using shitty Chinese, but when I misunderstand a comment in Chinese and ask stuff, I get told by other Chinese netizens that I'm not Chinese and I'll never be Chinese enough and uncultured and i should go dickride white people and then I report it, and nothing happens because I reported it with my fuckass Chinese. i get this sm now js because my IP says Canada because I'm visiting my family there rn. what the fuck. i hate my life i hate being told im an immigrant in one place and then when i actually go the fuck home back to my 'home country' i get told that im uncultured and stupid and "dickriding the west." can we delete all chinese men above 40 from the app please please please please please i cant stand ts anymore i would rather be on twitter and being spammed by bots like 'big boobed janette' than ts.

4 months ago
92
r/rednote

Hello Rednoters in the US, what is the common tags you will use and see in posts? Especially those are used in your context.

9 months ago
94
r/rednote

Foreigner purchases?

Does anyone know if Rednote will ever allow people in the US to buy stuff? I want to, but I dont have a Chinese number and so im not allowed to 😭

5 days ago
011
Is my account restricted?
r/rednote

Is my account restricted?

I just created my acc yesterday around 10:30pm after few hours ago and this happened. What to do?

5 days ago
38
r/rednote

I just answered an experience survey for rednote

I suggest everyone tries to answer it and complain about foreign users' moderation. It seems they are aware there's a problem and are willing to listen ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

7 days ago
01