Getting banned from RedNote

When they say they don't want political posts, they mean it. Even posting content like labor history will get you banned. Their view seems that anything that may interfere with a sense of social harmony between East and West will get you banned. Eugene Debs will get you banned. Black Panther Party content will get you banned. You want to make the argument for the conservative position? Also banned. If you think they want to promote socialism.... nope. They want to live in harmony with America and if you suggest there have been and continue to be problems with the United States they will ban you. If you promote left or right perspectives of history, they will ban you. No politics means NO POLITICS. It may seem odd to the Western mindset, but remember: the West values individualism, the East values social harmony and collectivism. It's their platform, their rules, and that's fine. Cultural values are very different. Leftists go and think RedBook is leftist and Conservatives go and think RedBook is conservative. It's just a different perspective on the world.

Share

Comments

nephelokokkygia•over 1 year ago•9

Why are you trying to post political content to the lifestyle app in the first place. Just talk about food like a normal person.

Puzzleheaded-Skin269•over 1 year ago•2

Don't bother trying to figure out China's censorship system. Even people who've been using the Chinese internet for years can't fully understand its rules—because there are no clear rules to begin with. As we Chinese say, "The law must remain unknowable, so its power remains unfathomable." The lack of clear guidelines is intentional, as it forces people to self-censor.

adeveloper2•over 1 year ago•2

the West values individualism, the East values social harmony and collectivism

That's a simplified view typical of Americans who are used to complicated subjects being dumbed down for them. There's nothing that "collectivist" about East Asians. Rather, Americans are generally far more narcissistic and self-serving so anything that's not "me me me" and "I am a special snowflake" may come off as "collectivist".

Also, the censorship you encountered has nothing to do with this and has everything about controlling the narrative. The CCP does not like insurrectionist movements. You will not find this type of censorship in Korea, Japan, or Taiwan.

Famous_Maintenance_5•over 1 year ago•2

To be fare, if you talk about politics in r/lifestyle or r/foodhacks , you'd probably be banned too.

Anxious-Yak-9952•over 1 year ago•2

That's honestly why I'm sticking around and I'm glad they're doing what's best for their platform.

Wonderful-Pilot-2423•over 1 year ago•2

You're so close to getting it... There's no politics because the CCP wants no politics.

rkwalton•over 1 year ago•2

Look, I've been to China a few times, and the government is serious things like that. I remember being in Shanghai once. I was in my hotel room. CNN was on, and it was the anniversary of Tiananmen Square. I was getting ready and then suddenly the TV broadcast stopped. At first, I was like, "Did the power go out?" But no, the lights were on and everything else was fine. I remembered where I was, and that was that.

Their app. Their rules.

I'm not touching politics on that app.

PersonalityOk4660•over 1 year ago•1

I've seen lots of political posts in the past few days and they are still up.

Reptillary_Clinton•over 1 year ago•1

It’s so funny I keep seeing people say this when the app is literally named “little red book” a book written by Mao.

Capital_Click_5029•over 1 year ago•1

It’s fine to have political posts as long as it’s pro-China or anti-American

More like this

r/rednote

Red note

Isnt is kinda beautiful to see how Americans and the Chinese are getting along. It’s the most connected we’ve ever been with each other and most users are accepting us. Granted, we will have to limit brain rot and post high quality content, but it’s nice to a lot of us getting along

over 1 year ago
70· 96%16
r/rednote

I didn't even use tiktok, and this app is awesome and has a great community,Coming from YouTube shorts.

Chinese and Americans have never been closer to each other until now. This app is really wholesome tbh and the fact its free of brainrot too

over 1 year ago
62· 96%4
r/rednote

The living standards of Chinese people presented on Xiaohongshu are exaggerated (This is not a question, but it's very helpful for TTrefugees to understand this Chinese app)

I'm Chinese. The lives of Chinese people are not as good as shown on Xiaohongshu If you are a blogger on Xiaohongshu, and you interview ordinary people in ordinary counties about their daily lives and daily expenses, your videos will be banned soon because ordinary people live in poverty (even China's former Premier Li Keqiang said that 600 million people in China earn less than 1000 yuan per month), and showing these poor lives to the public is not allowed in China because it will deepen people's doubts about the effectiveness of the Communist Party's economic policies. When Xiaohongshu first became popular in China (I don’t mean when Xiaohongshu was first established), it was an app about female consumption and entertainment, and as a result, a serious comparison culture was formed on this app. This culture led to a phenomenon called “refined poverty”, which means that young people with limited incomes spend a lot of money (even borrowing high-interest loans) on some items and services that can show off their wealth on social media, while being very tight on other aspects of life. Therefore, generally speaking, the content about Chinese people's lives that you can see on Xiaohongshu is posted by middle-class people living in big cities and people who are poisoned by the culture of "refined poverty". Ordinary people are too embarrassed to post their ordinary lives on it. Even if they do, if they post too much, their posts will be deleted or their accounts will be blocked. So, I can say that the content about life you can see on Xiaohongshu is exaggerated. The content on Xiaohongshu cannot reflect the real living standards of Chinese people.

over 1 year ago
56· 77%45
indefinite restriction, denied passport verification…3
r/rednote

indefinite restriction, denied passport verification…

i’m australian born chinese. some of my interests are really niche globally, but has lots of fanartists in china. i’m friends with them on global platforms like xwitter, but they post much more here and also it’s more lively.. i’d really love to see their works (guess i still can, i just can’t share anymore.) so far the changes in my account that i noticed is a fully resetted profile name, pictures, bio. people won’t see my profile and posts, and i can’t make new posts or comment. they’ve restricted the feature to delete this account and make a new one..? it doesn’t bother me cuz i just started, but i’m still a little sad. ive tried the automated appeal with my passport. i dont care if they get my information but when i tried to give my details, it needed me to NFC scan my passport. the facial recognition failed many times since my lighting was too bright. after the 7th try they got it, but said my phone is “unsafe”, therefore it’s not valid. is there just no way around it… ive said absolutely nothing to no one, i like art posts and finally decided to post my own drawings (with my desc text in chinese). did i post too many within 30 minutes??? whatd i even do so far bilibili has been the most kind app to me, taobao has also banned me at one point should i pack it up and leave

3 days ago
65
Help with package returned2
r/rednote

Help with package returned

I had a package from xiaohongshu shipped to the Cainiao warehouse, but they rejected my package with a message that said it will be returned to the seller via the original route. I was told that when a package is rejected by Cainiao, it will be returned to the sender via the same tracking number. I’m trying to fill out the Return Details on xiaohongshu, but it’s not letting me enter the same tracking number. So what should I do??

4 days ago
20
r/rednote

Chiboki consolidated shipping

Is there any way to get around the consolidated shipping and just pay the shipping up front, or is that not an option within red-note? I’m worried about how much the shipping will be because I want to order 13 squishes and would wanna know the price before I end up purchasing them

5 days ago
13