Would hiring a social media manager help me actually start posting consistently?

I manage social media for clients and yes. It’s hard to say what you’d need without knowing what you’re creating. I think a social media manager would suffice for most of what you’ve mentioned here. I’d love to help get you started in exchange for a review! Otherwise, there’s a social media manager subreddit that’s full of agencies of all sizes or you could look locally and see if there are any agencies or freelancers that vibe well with you!

There are so many parts to social media management. Decide what you want help with vs. what you want to do yourself.

For example, you could have someone come up with a strategy and you actually do the execution of creating the content. Or you could have someone come up with a strategy and also create the content (this would be a bigger investment). Or they can play some role in content creation while you do some of the work. It depends on what kind of content you want to create and what role you would like to play. (Example: You could write all the content and the social media manager creates graphics based on your writing.)

Maybe for now you could just find someone to do an audit or consultation or something. Then you could decide whether or not you want to work with them for additional work.

You can post on Reddit about looking for a social media strategist or manager (not in this sub though, because it's against the rules). Another idea is to make a post on LinkedIn, not even an official "LinkedIn job post" but just a normal post on your feed, like a status update. "Hey, I'm looking for a social media manager. Here's what I need help with..." and describe what you're looking for.

Something important wherever you post your job is to describe your brand, and link to your website. This will help social media managers know whether or not they're a good fit for your brand. Hire someone who already has knowledge or experience working with your type of brand or something similar, not someone whose only experience is completely different brands that are in other niches.

What do you like to post about?

I think this is actually something a Social Media Manager with a strong content strategy background could help you with.

From what you described, you already have a clear goal: building your personal/professional presence and establishing yourself as someone worth following in your field. The issue seems to be less about knowing why you want to post and more about having a system that makes posting easier and prevents you from overthinking every piece of content.

Since you specifically want help with content ideas, planning, editing, and scheduling, I’d lean toward a Social Media Manager who also understands content strategy rather than hiring a strategist alone. A strategist can help you figure out the direction, but an SMM can help turn that strategy into actual content and keep things moving consistently.

A good SMM could also take some of the decision-making pressure off you. Instead of constantly asking yourself what to post, whether something is good enough, or whether people will like it, you’d have an agreed-upon content plan and someone helping you execute it. Many SMMs work with 30, 60, or 90-day content plans, although the exact process depends on the person.

For the “I still want it to sound like me” part, I’d make that very clear when hiring someone. A good SMM shouldn't completely replace your voice with generic social media language. They should learn your tone, opinions, personality, and the way you naturally communicate, then use those as the foundation for the content.

For budget, $500–$1,000+ per month can be a reasonable range for freelance social media management, but it depends heavily on the scope. Someone only creating a content plan will obviously cost less than someone handling strategy, content creation, editing, scheduling, community management, analytics, and reporting.

As for where to find someone, you could look at LinkedIn, Reddit, Upwork, Fiverr, or referrals. I’d focus less on finding the cheapest option and more on finding someone whose portfolio shows that they can actually develop a content strategy and adapt to a person's voice. Since this is a personal/professional brand, I'd also look for someone who has experience with personal brands.

And honestly, I don't think hiring an SMM for this is overkill. If the main thing stopping you from building your presence is overthinking and lack of structure, having someone create that structure and keep you accountable could be exactly what you're looking for.

I'm a social media manager working with clients in different fields and the short answer is... yes, definitely. The problems you're facing are the ones my clients talk about the most - overthinking, focusing on vanity metrics, and not really knowing what works. Everything that you've mentioned is stuff a social media manager could do for you, but it's completely up to you how much control you want, so the process can be built around you!

If you are tech savvy there is AI for that

Not remotely worth spending the money on…

Social media management firms (or ‘brand managers’ as they hilariously refer to themselves as now) can sometimes be a justifiable expense for start-up companies, new restaurants, independent handymen, etc…

The cost for them isn’t cheap either. So what would likely happen in your case, would be they’d give you a slightly cheaper rate than what they’d charge a new steakhouse, and they’d pawn you off on some new intern…

You can get everything you need and so much more from simply subscribing to an AI platform for $20-$30/month, and watching a handful of videos on YouTube that will educate how to properly and effectively communicate to your AI exactly what it is that you’d like to your weekly output to be, and to even teach you how to train the AI to create stuff everyday for you to post without you even needing to ask.

TLDR; You’re better off doing some research on which AI platform best suits what you’re looking for and spending the $25/month on that as opposed to paying the exceedingly insulting prices that these social media firms charge. Because to be honest with you, they’re just going to use the AI shit to make your stuff..

A social media professional can help, but the useful hire is not someone who simply takes posting away from you. Your bottleneck mixes positioning, decision fatigue, production, and fear of judgment.

Start with a short paid workflow sprint rather than a broad monthly retainer. You should leave it with three or four content themes, examples of what you will and will not say, a simple capture process for raw ideas, a repeatable review step, and a small publishing calendar.

Keep ownership of the opinions and final voice. They can turn notes into drafts, edit, schedule, and keep the process moving. A strategist is useful for the initial message and system. A manager or editor is useful once the recurring work is clear.

Ask candidates to show how they preserve a client's voice, what they need from you each week, what deliverables are included, and how revisions work. Judge the first month by whether you publish consistently with less decision time, not by promised follower growth. If the process still depends on you inventing every post from a blank page, the role was scoped incorrectly.

If this post doesn't follow the rules, please report it to the mods.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

Yes.

Just based on the what you've shared, your core problem right now is you don't really know what you're doing - hence the: "I can spend way too long thinking about a simple post and then end up posting nothing."

Essentially you don't have a clear strategy.

Your secondary problem is that you're investing emotion into a something that should be a process.

When you are posting on social media with some sort of outcome in mind, you don't want to get sucked into the social media buzz. You want to have reports coming in periodically from a strategist who gives you a competent overview and plan for the next period of time (For example a plan for next weeks content schedule.)

A social media manager essentially takes all the negative "personal" out of social media and runs it like a business.

- Without knowing much more, it sounds like a content strategist would fit your situation quite well.