i helped him go from a few thousand views to 100k+. now he hates what we make.

i help a guy with his content, and lately i feel weird taking any credit for the numbers.

he makes beautiful short videos, properly shot, with a lot of thought behind the lighting and the edit. those usually get a few thousand views. his work needs the reach, so i suggested trying some of what's already working. copying trending concepts and formats, adapting them to his style, using trending audio.

those started clearing 100k, some way past that. it kept happening, and eventually ā€œlet’s try a fewā€ turned into most of what we make.

when we first started working together, we'd spend our conversations talking about shots, where the light would be, how long to hold on something. now we're mostly talking about whether a trend is still alive and if we can get ours posted in time.

he told me he feels like he's losing a little piece of his soul for views. i didnt really know what to say because i'm the one who encouraged it, and the reason i gave him still holds up: more people are seeing his work.

except i'm starting to wonder what that's worth if the work they're seeing is stuff he doesn't want to make.

i don't think the trend videos are beneath him or that being proud of something means it deserves 100k views. but we went into this thinking the trend stuff would bring enough attention to support the work he actually cared about. instead, every time we plan one of his original ideas, we're comparing it to what following a trend could do, and it gets harder to justify spending the time.

for people who manage accounts for a living, have you actually made that balance work? i'm interested in how you decide what gets made when the stuff your client loves consistently gets a fraction of the views. we said we'd keep doing both, but that hasn't meant much in practice.

Share

Comments

MrMigOfficial•about 1 month ago•17

They need fo figure out what the end goal is. Its not about what they want, its about what gets the job done.

Highlad•about 1 month ago•4

As a videographer, I get where he's coming from. It entirely depends on the purpose of it. If this is a creative outlet for him then make it that. Spend the energy on creativity.

If it's a job then you need to grow an audience, and that 'visual creativity' takes a back seat.

If he wants both then he's going to need a team, so that he can focus on what he loves (cinematography) and someone else can take the reigns on content direction.

Beautiful-Newt8179•about 1 month ago•3

Not entirely comparable, but Iā€˜m building my own author account - and there’s a very similar balance there, because Iā€˜m writing in a genre that’s not trending.

Thing is, I could work out how to write a trending book and how to sell it. But it wouldn’t make me happy. Now, it’s a struggle to even find readers at all. But every time I do…it’s so worth it. And those readers are mostly loving my book.

So what’s the plan? Long-term success. Itā€˜ll probably take 10-15 books before I have a chance to live from this. Right now I don’t even break even (not even close). Even moderate success is easily 5-10 years away.

But that’s where Iā€˜m heading. Figuring out how to reach readers in my niche, improving my craft and understanding NOT what the masses of readers want, but what MY readers want - both in the books I write and the marketing I do.

Is this hard some days? Absolutely. But to me, it’s worth it. And you can absolutely optimize beyond ā€œwhat’s trendingā€ and focus on ā€œwhat’s reaching YOUR audienceā€œ. You just have to be very aware that it’s a long road.

BINAYAUDIO•about 1 month ago•2

You have to be clear with your goals. For example in your whole post you don't mention what he is trying to achieve. Is he a videographer trying to get more clients to hire him to direct short movies? That's the thing you have to figure out.

Being able to scale views like you did is an amazing skill but it needs a purpose.

If your client is trying to be an influence that's powerful. If your client is trying to connect with people who would hire him for his experience and you're showing none of that and making his profile seen by a mainstream audience rather than his niche then that's a disservice.
So it really depends what he is trying to achieve and that's the first thing to determine to create the content with that goal in mind.

(I'm not able to make 100k videos)

AutoModerator•about 1 month ago•1

If this post doesn't follow the rules, please report it to the mods.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

More like this

r/socialmedia

My client took six days to approve a post and then asked why it flopped

I sent this client a finished post on a Monday morning. Nothing complicated, just a promo that was tied to a date that week. It sat there. I nudged once on Wednesday, politely. I got a thumbs up emoji back, which I have learned means nothing at all. The actual approval came Friday night, six days later, after the promo date had already passed and the moment the post was built for was gone. We posted a version of it anyway because they still wanted it up. On Monday they asked why reach was so low compared to the last promo. I did not handle it perfectly in the moment. I wanted to say the post did not flop, the timing did, and the timing was not mine. What I actually did after that was put a simple rule in writing for the next month: approvals come back within two business days, and if they come back late, the post date moves with them. No rush rebuilds, no quiet absorbing of a missed window. One named person approves, not a group thread where everyone assumes someone else looked. They agreed, mostly because I showed them the dates in a row. Sent Monday, nudged Wednesday, approved Friday night, posted late, results low. Seeing it as a timeline made it hard to argue with. It has been better since, not perfect. Approvals still drift when they get busy, but now at least the schedule drift is visible and it is shared. How do you handle late approvals? Do you move the date, charge a rush fee, or just post late and let the numbers say what they say?

11 days ago
19Ā· 100%10
r/socialmedia

How many rounds of revisions before a post stops being yours? I just watched a good idea die on round 4.

I do social for a few small clients. Last week I wrote a post I was actually proud of. Timely, a little funny, sounded like a real person. Then it went into approvals. Round 1, the hook got softened. Round 2, the joke came out. Round 3, the caption got rewritten to sound more like the brand, which apparently means more like a brochure. Round 4, someone senior who does not spend any time on the platform weighed in and we started over. The final version took 8 days to publish. It is fine. It is also something I would scroll right past. My question for other freelancers: do you cap revision rounds in your contract, and has anyone actually enforced it when a client pushed past the cap? I am thinking two rounds max, then we talk. Curious if that holds up in real life or if clients just laugh at it.

22 days ago
19Ā· 100%15
r/socialmedia

Why doesn’t Apple make a social media platform given all the major privacy concerns out of the popular platforms.

microsoft owns linkedin (imo that is social media). google owns youtube. maybe it is time for Apple to start a social media given the rise of Muse creating personal dossiers on all of its users (Meta - Facebook, Instagram, Whatsapp). or even acquire one? I would love to use something other than tiktok, snapchat, instagram, youtube, or linkedin. apple?

about 1 month ago
18Ā· 100%37
r/socialmedia

Weekly Hiring Thread: Social Media Professionals

This is our weekly thread for all hiring and job-seeking posts. All standalone hiring posts will be removed, please use this thread instead. **If You're Hiring:** * Start your comment with \[HIRING\] * Include job title and location (or Remote) * Specify if it's full-time, part-time, contract, or freelance * Must be a paid opportunity (include salary range or rate if possible) * Describe the role, required skills, and how to apply * No equity-only or commission-only positions **If You're Job Seeking:** * Start your comment with \[FOR HIRE\] * Include your specialty and experience level * List your key skills and services * Share your availability and preferred work arrangement * Link to portfolio or relevant work samples **Rules:** * One top-level comment per job posting or job seeker * All conversations about a specific posting must remain as nested replies under that comment * Follow all r/socialmedia community guidelines * No spec work, competitions, or unpaid opportunities * Report any spam or rule violations Good luck to everyone hiring and job hunting this week.

about 22 hours ago
14
r/socialmedia

How do you compare a prospect's socials to their competitors for a pitch without paying for a yearly tool?

I'm freelance and every pitch for a new account gets one slide putting the prospect's Instagram and TikTok next to two competitors, mostly follower growth and average views per post. The analytics tools I've looked at all sell yearly seats and I only pitch two or three times a month, so right now I'm counting views by hand off each profile. What numbers do you show at that stage, and does anyone on the other side of the table care?

1 day ago
27
r/socialmedia

Posting content across 10+ accts

I'm thinking about creating 10 different accounts and creating AI content on each of them. Do I need 10 separate phones for this? Do I need unique IPs for each? Are there certain rules I have to follow so that I'm not shadowbaned?

1 day ago
07