These comments are interesting. I actually tend to get the most engagement/conversion from my “oversharing” posts because I frame it like: hey, if you’re also struggling with this weird/niche/difficult feeling, you’re not as alone as you feel.
For example, if I post about the specific struggles I’m facing from my mental illness/disability OR ways that I cope with those feelings OR how low I was vs how far I’ve come (the more detail the better), I get a huge influx of follows + comments & DMs thanking me for posting so vulnerably. It’s personal. It makes people feel seen. And it helps my audience know/feel connected to me.
In contrast, when I pull back and start overthinking how I am perceived, my engagement/conversion takes a hit. People don’t care as much about my content or keeping up with my page when all I am posting is polished social-media-worthy highlights. they don’t feel like they really know me.
If you’re building a personal page/brand, I think the trick to oversharing is doing it candidly (and not incessantly) instead of trying to farm sympathy. The former can be extremely valuable to both the creator and their audience. The latter is just annoying.
Yes it is scary as fuck to hit post though 😂 especially when people I know irl will see it. I always need to remind myself that cringe is a made up concept I shant concern myself with lol.