Hot take: most small accounts don't need more followers, they need a reason for the ones they have to come back

I keep seeing people with 300-800 followers chase growth hacks, collabs, hashtags, trending audio, all to get new eyes.

But when I look at their profiles, there's no reason to come back. Every post is a different topic, a different style, no series, nothing to look forward to.

My take: until 1 in 10 of your current followers would actually notice if you stopped posting, getting more followers mostly just makes the numbers bigger, not the account better.

Pick one recurring thing (a weekly breakdown, a series, a running joke, whatever) and do it until people expect it.

Am I wrong? Did anyone here grow by focusing on reach first and it worked out?

Share

Comments

VesselArchive•9 days ago•3

Mostly agree, with one caveat for local businesses: at 300 followers a lot of them are friends and family, not people who'd ever buy, so some reach chasing is fair early on. The series idea still works for both though. A recurring format like a weekly before and after, or answering one real customer question every Tuesday, gives the right people a reason to come back, and it's way easier to make consistently because you aren't reinventing the post every time.

Boring-Surround2657•9 days ago•2

That 1 in 10 cutoff feels too precise for something you cannot really measure. Repeat commenters or people asking for the next part would give you a clearer signal that the recurring format is working.

DigitalOutreachHQ•9 days ago•2

Yes, focusing for reach first works. For one of our accounts, we kept following a colour, image and content theme, basically building a brand look and creating a reach. It created a signature style and an instant recall value. And it worked. Now people associate the style and colour scheme with the brand and even the content writing style. So creating and sticking to one identify can work for finding the right audience and increasing the reach. However, with forever changing algorithm these things vary from brand to brand.

Would love to know more on this.

ThrowawayFoxKit•9 days ago•1

Theres other reasons like getting to 1k for live gifts if you havent already got it. 1k for the music thing you can make money off. Video gifts at 10k so yeah maybe after that point you are better to focus on your content

noahberg_cs•9 days ago•1

the series thing worked for a client of ours but only once we put it on the calendar as a fixed slot, same day every week. the moment it was 'whenever we have time' it died in a month lol

NetrusCreates•7 days ago•1

I think there's a lot of truth to this. It's easy to get caught up in follower counts, especially when you're managing a smaller channel.

I've been experimenting with different types of music and animated videos, and I'm starting to think that giving viewers something recognizable to return for is just as important as reaching new people.

A thousand followers who actually look forward to your next upload seem much more valuable than ten thousand who barely remember following you.

AutoModerator•9 days ago•1

If this post doesn't follow the rules, please report it to the mods.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

Icy_Statistician1483•9 days ago•1

agree, and brands notice it too. a page of 800 with a clear reason to come back (a weekly series, a recurring question, a format people expect) reads stronger than a big page of random posts. pick one thing your followers can count on every week, then judge growth after a month of it

More like this

r/socialmedia

What is engagement on LinkedIn?

Everyone talks about "boosting engagement" but nobody actually breaks down what that means practically. Likes, comments, shares, clicks they all count differently and yet most people treat them the same. From what I have seen comments carry the most weight both for the algorithm and for actual human memory. When someone leaves a genuinely thoughtful comment I remember their name way longer than whoever wrote the original post. Is that just me or does anyone else experience linkedIn that way?

7 months ago
12· 100%6
r/socialmedia

Anyone started a paid community??

Hey everyone, I have around 25 000 subscribers on YouTube and 10k on instagram. I’m barely generating any revenue from like ads, but my community is very engaged. I’ve been recommended starting a paid community on like [Meplio](https://meplio.com/) or [Skool](https://www.skool.com/) has anyone actually made any money like this? Thank you!

3 months ago
11· 100%3
r/socialmedia

Does posting consistently actually matter if the content isn't great?

I’ve always wondered how much consistency really matters compared with simply posting less often but having something genuinely useful or interesting to say. There seems to be a lot of pressure to post every day now. For people who actually manage social accounts, what have you seen work better: posting frequently, or posting only when you have something worth putting out? And has that changed depending on the platform?

about 1 month ago
10· 100%62
r/socialmedia

Portfolio Check SMM

So I've been applying for almost 2 weeks now, and I still can't get to the next stage. And i think my portfolio is the problem. If you have time, pls check my portfolio and tell me whats wrong and whats needed to be improved. Here's my portfolio: [https://portfolio-smm-git-main-220000001074s-projects.vercel.app/](https://portfolio-smm-git-main-220000001074s-projects.vercel.app/)

about 21 hours ago
11
r/socialmedia

This is regarding how much to charge.

Basically at this point, I don’t know how much brands are willing to pay. How do other creators charge? I want to know, I’m very curious. I have about 48k followers, with good reach.. almost 150-300k views per reel and i make food recipes content. Can someone help me with this? Agencies don’t wanna pay even half of the rates. It’s really getting difficult to make money here 😭

about 21 hours ago
39
r/socialmedia

What's effective way to do organic marketing on Reddit.

/r/digital_marketing/comments/1m4qu1y/whats_effective_way_to_do_organic_marketing_on/

1 day ago
18