Followers don't automatically turn into sales, and I think the gap is usually on the website

Something I keep noticing with small brands: the Instagram or TikTok account feels alive. Real customers in the comments, try-on videos, people tagging the brand. Then you click through to the store and it's studio shots on a white background and nothing else. Everything that made you trust the brand stayed behind on the app.

A few reasons I think followers convert worse than people expect:

  • The trust built on social doesn't travel with the click. People land on a product page that feels like a colder, different brand.
  • Most followers are there for the content, not to shop right now. A follow is closer to "I like this" than "I'll buy this."
  • The path from a post to the product is clumsy: link in bio, then the homepage, then searching for the thing they saw.
  • The proof people look for, real people actually wearing or using the product, lives on social and not where the buying decision happens.

What seems to help is keeping some of that real content in front of people at the moment they're deciding, and making the jump from a post to the exact product as short as possible.

Curious how others handle it. If you run social for a brand that sells online, do you bring your social content onto the website, or treat social purely as an awareness channel?

Share

Comments

AutoModerator•1 day ago•1

If this post doesn't follow the rules, please report it to the mods.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

VladMnu•1 day ago•1

The clumsy path point is the one I see most with clients. Someone watches a 20 second video, taps through, lands on a homepage and has to go hunting for the exact item. Most people just give up there.

What helped on one account was linking each post to the specific product page, not the store front, and putting one short customer video on that page near the buy button. It did not need a redesign. It just made the page feel like the same brand they had just come from, and clicks started turning into actual orders a bit more often.

Capable-Parsnip-9163•about 14 hours ago•1

I think the real gap is context, not trust. On social, people watch the product being lived with. On the site, they're suddenly asked to judge it alone, like reading someone's resume after you already liked them in person.

The brands that convert well treat the product page as the next scene, not a new story. Same faces, same tone, same proof. Honestly, most stores I click through feel like a different brand entirely.

More like this

r/socialmedia

Social media is definitely over glamorized… As someone who quit there 9-5 & started working full time as a content creator who makes roughly 4-6k a month

Definitely changed my life & gives me so much more free time but also ruined my life. Its been 2 years & im slowly starting to hate it , especially as somebody who runs everything by themselves with no help. It’s a lot more than people think and actually having control over everything and choosing your own schedule is much harder than some people think you have to push yourself more to make the content to engage to produce to push yourself to a new extreme and much more, I will say I’ve learned a lot, but I’ve also lost a lot , my brain chemistry will never be the same again after this job, which I’m OK with that, but there’s a lot more to it than what people say, especially in the industry that I work in

23 days ago
120· 71%43
r/socialmedia

What social media trend are you noticing right now?

Social media feels very different in 2026. A few things I’ve noticed: \* AI content is everywhere, so real human content stands out more. \* Small niche creators often have stronger communities than huge pages. \* People now use Instagram, TikTok, Reddit and YouTube like search engines. \* Short-form video is still huge, but useful content performs better than random clips. \* Building a community is becoming more valuable than just gaining followers. I think the biggest trend is simple: \*\*Content is getting easier to create, but trust is getting harder to earn.\*\*

13 days ago
99· 100%32
r/socialmedia

I sold ad space on my toilet and it went viral (100M views)

This will sound absurd, but it’s completely true. A few months ago, I started selling ad space on my toilet with the goal to make $1,000,000. It started off as a joke and quickly became not a joke, with 25 major companies spending over $125,000 to purchase ad space. The series has gone completely viral and even got me on the news. I think it’s a fun story so I want to break it down here - why it’s working, what it’s like working with these brands, and how you could do something like this yourself. \*\*How it happened\*\* \- I got the idea from the Red Paperclip story: split my toilet into sections, put a price on each one, better spots cost more, and projection map every logo on with its own animation \- I made a fake demo with Microsoft Teams to test it. It blew up and brands flooded the comments, but none of them were serious, they just wanted the impressions \- So I manufactured the first real deal. I showed MoonPay all the other brands commenting, they said yes, and I used that yes as leverage to close everyone else \- I posted once a day for the first two weeks. Every video told viewers to tag companies, and the more companies joined, the more wanted in \- Then I switched to a flat fee that keeps going up, plus a King of The Throne top spot. So far 25 companies have bought in, spots from $1,000 to $17,000, over $125,000 total, and 100M+ views on my projection mapping videos **Why it's working** \- It's a good story. "Unemployed guy tries to make $1,000,000 from his toilet" is a lot catchier than "experienced marketer makes ads," even though both are true \- I'm the underdog, so the audience sees themselves in it and feels like they could do it too \- It's never been done and it can't be copied. People sell ad space on other things now, but there's only one toilet guy \- People actually want to watch these ads and cheer for the next one. That almost never happens \- The Quality Paradox: the video I spend 5 minutes on beats the one I spend 5 months on. People want the guy figuring it out, not the polished final product **What I learned from working with 30 brands** \- Every brand is different. The hands off ones let me do whatever I want, the hands on ones had specific messaging. I had more fun with the hands off ones \- $10,000 sounds insane for one video until you realize I'm the entire studio: idea, script, design, animation, VFX, marketing. A studio charges $100,000 for that, and the brand gets my audience on top of it **How you can do this too** \- Cold outreach doesn't land brand deals. It works for freelance clients, but brands come to you when you prove yourself \- Views aren't proof. Brands need to see the exact concept they're buying \- Make your own series that involves brands: remake logos, design merch, make fake products, whatever fits you. It has to be yours and you have to actually enjoy it \- Be your own agent. Half of me makes the videos, the other half fights to get them seen \- Take the long shots. I sent dozens of DMs and emails to news stations and media, 99% got ignored. Worst case is a minute of embarrassment, the upside is unlimited \- None of it works if it isn't unapologetically you Hope you enjoyed! Lmk if you have any questions

2 days ago
53· 33%15
r/socialmedia

Does building in public works for new social accounts which are warned for a few days/weeks?

I've heard a lot that build in public works only for people who have the presence of more than 10+years on social platforms. So is there any way for new people to get into this?

2 days ago
02
r/socialmedia

My best post this month got 40k views and zero bookings. What do you actually put in a client report?

Genuine question for the freelancers and small agency folks here. Last month my best performing post for a client hit about 40k views, a pile of saves, comments I was proud of. The client looked at the report, nodded at all of it, and then asked the only question that mattered to them: did anyone actually book? Bookings from that post: zero. I had no good answer, because my whole report was reach, engagement rate, follower growth. All true, none of it connected to their money. Since then I have been rebuilding how I report. I track enquiries and bookings first, even if the attribution is messy and I have to say so. Saves and replies go in as supporting signals, not the headline. The awkward part is that some months the honest numbers look worse than the vanity version, and I worry a client would rather see the pretty chart. So what do you actually put in a monthly report? Do you lead with business outcomes even when they are flat? How do you handle attribution when a booking clearly came from social but you cannot prove which post did it? And has anyone lost a client by being too honest in a report, or is that just my fear talking?

2 days ago
13
r/socialmedia

Managing multiple social platforms feels like managing several separate jobs

for people handling social media across multiple platforms, how do you keep everything manageable? between creating content, adapting creatives for different platforms, scheduling posts, checking analytics, and running paid campaigns, it seems like there's always another dashboard to check. do you use separate tools for each task, an all-in-one platform, or a mix of tools and spreadsheets? i'm curious which part of the workflow takes the most effort for you. is it creating content, keeping everything organised, understanding performance, or something else? would be interested to hear what your actual setup looks like, especially if you're doing this without a large team.

2 days ago
49