I tracked my hours for 3 months. My $900 retainer was really a $500 one.

I would track hours on a flat retainer, not to bill every minute, but to verify the scope, effective rate, and workload assumptions. Review the numbers monthly or quarterly, before the drift becomes a year of unpaid additions.

The agreement should name the included deliverables, platforms, revision rounds, meetings, community-management hours, response window, and add-on rates. When an extra request becomes recurring, quote it before absorbing it. A useful automatic trigger is two consecutive months more than 15% over the expected hours, which starts a scope review.

Leading with the data and two clear choices was strong. I would also track gross margin and after-hours work, because a retainer can look profitable while quietly consuming the time needed for other clients.

For clients on a fixed fee contract I still send an hourly breakdown with the invoice every month. That way there's a record of scope creep and if hours start to go way over the agreed upon retainer tier.

If this post doesn't follow the rules, please report it to the mods.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

Track hours, price flat. The tracking is for you, so you see the effective rate before a year of drift builds up. The price stays simple for the client.

Leading with the data was the right call. A few things the comments haven't covered:

- Make the scope report permanent. Send it monthly, with the hours column on it. The next conversation then takes two minutes, because nothing has piled up unseen.

- Name the weekend replies. Put a response window in the agreement, for example business hours only, with weekend cover as a paid add on. Absorbing it quietly teaches the client that it's free.

- When a one-off request turns up a second time, tell them it's now an add on before you do it a third time.

Now, something from co-founding Angels Management, a creator management company, in November 2021. The idea we worked to was that management earns its percentage by changing the numbers, and if the creator would have got there anyway, you are a cost. A retainer follows the same test. Your scope report put what changed next to what it cost, so the client could see what they were buying. A fee holds when the client can see what moved.